Court leaves company stuck with legal bills

Posted 11/17/26

Telecommunications provider TCT won’t be able to recoup the millions of dollars that it spent defending a class action lawsuit, a federal appeals court has confirmed.

TCT contends that its …

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

E-mail
Password
Log in

Court leaves company stuck with legal bills

Posted

Telecommunications provider TCT won’t be able to recoup the millions of dollars that it spent defending a class action lawsuit, a federal appeals court has confirmed.

TCT contends that its former insurer should have paid for its defense in a 2015 suit. However, the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals confirmed this month that the insurer is off the hook, effectively leaving TCT stuck with the bills.

The litigation stemmed from TCT’s 2015 conversion from a member-owned, nonprofit cooperative to a private, for-profit company. A state district judge ultimately dismissed the suit in 2022 and the Wyoming Supreme Court affirmed that decision in 2023, ending the battle in TCT’s favor.

Despite the win, TCT was still out the more than $4 million that it spent on attorneys and other costs during the eight years of litigation. 

TCT headed to federal court in 2024 to argue that its previous insurer, Hartford subsidiary Twin City Fire Insurance, should cover the legal bills. However, U.S. District Court Judge Kelly Rankin ruled in February that, under the terms of its policy, Twin City was not obligated to defend TCT; that’s largely because the suit was brought by one of the TCT coop’s former directors — a so-called “insured versus insured” situation — and was filed within a year of the director’s service on the board.

TCT appealed Rankin’s decision to the 10th Circuit, but on Nov. 3, a three-judge panel unanimously agreed that the 2015 suit wasn’t covered by the insurance policy.

Comments

No comments on this story    Please log in to comment by clicking here
Please log in or register to add your comment