Partly Cloudy

46°F

Powell, WY

Partly Cloudy

Humidity: 15%

Wind: 14 mph

EDITORIAL: Sentencing guidelines could help Equality State

Though theft comes in several different varieties, it all generally fits into one simple definition: You betray someone’s trust and take something that doesn’t belong to you.

If you tried to define theft based off of the sentences handed down in Park County’s courts over the past couple years, however, you might have a hard time telling they were for the same type of thing.

Consider the following crimes and sentences handed down since late 2015:

Crime Sentence
Embezzling $5,162 from a nonprofit 0 days in jail
Shoplifting $558.88 worth of items (and drug possession) 4 days in jail
Trying to shoplift a $4.13 item 10 days in jail
Trying to shoplift $95.81 worth of items 10 days in jail
Allegedly embezzling $9,633.71 from a professional organization 15 days in jail (proposed)
Embezzling $20,420.21 from an employer 30 days in jail
Trying to shoplift $24.46 worth of items 60 days in jail
Shoplifting $535.75 worth of merchandise and fleeing 82-85 days in jail
Stealing more than $1,100 in cash dropped on the floor of a business 90 days in jail 
Trying to shoplift $25.86 worth of items 90 days in jail

When considered individually, each of the punishments can be defended: Many of the harsh shoplifting sentences were an attempt to put a halt to a seemingly endless string of thefts from Walmart last year; several of the more severe ones are due to the defendants having prior criminal records; and several of the lighter sentences were handed to people with clean records who agreed to repay their ill-gotten gains at the time of sentencing.

But let’s zoom out for a moment: Does it really seem fair or equitable for a $25 theft to net three months in jail, a $20,000 theft one month and a $5,000 theft no time?

We would submit that it simply does not.

To be sure, jail and prison time is only one component and measure of a sentence. For example, the man who embezzled $5,162 from a local nonprofit received a felony conviction — something that may limit his job opportunities and privileges as a U.S. citizen for the rest of his life.

We also understand there are countless factors that go into a particular defendant’s sentence: How strong is the evidence against them? Did police do a good job investigating their case? Have they expressed remorse and accepted responsibility for their actions? Do they have a history of criminal conduct? Does the victim want to see their thief sit in jail or prefer to simply be paid back in a timely manner?

In short, there is an inherent risk in comparing sentences, because every case and every defendant is different. But we also believe that crimes — that is, a defendant’s actions — can and should be compared in an attempt to reach fair, consistent sentences. The disparities in the recent theft cases are not an isolated issue.

On top of that, some of the factors that affect how a defendant is treated by the criminal justice system — such as their financial means, which determine whether they can make bond or hire a top-of-the-line attorney — are unfair and inequitable.

To move toward greater fairness, we would encourage Wyoming’s lawmakers and officials in the judicial branch to explore the possibility of adopting sentencing guidelines.

The federal court system works under such rules. When a defendant appears before a U.S. District Court judge for sentencing in Casper or Cheyenne, various factors like criminal history are assigned point values in different categories and added up; the totals are ultimately plugged into a big table, which lists a limited range of possible sentences for the judge to impose.

At its best, such as a system promotes “equal justice under the law.”

Somewhere around half of the states have some form of sentencing guidelines.

In a 2008 study that reviewed the fairness and consistency of sentences in Virginia, Minnesota and Michigan, the nonprofit National Association of State Courts found that guidelines in those states, “result in greater consistency in deciding who goes to prison and for how long.”

“Guidelines also produce differentiated punishment: like cases are treated alike while unlike cases result in different degrees of punishment severity,” the authors from the association wrote. “These findings stand in marked contrast to the inconsistent and discriminatory sentencing practices documented in all three states prior to the implementation of guidelines.”

Without a doubt, a cold, hard spreadsheet cannot replace the insight of a living, breathing judge and should not impossibly bind their hands. But the same things that can make a judge good at their job — empathy and an ability to really understand a defendant — can also make it difficult for them to put a certain case in context with similar crimes, missing the forest for the trees.

That’s the essence of why we would like to see Wyoming consider sentencing guidelines: Justice may be blind, but it can’t afford to be nearsighted.

1 comment

  • posted by Tipper

    August 14, 2017 3:51 pm

    It's still a "not what you know - it's who you know" world around these parts. Get yourself entrenched into the establishment and you've pretty much got yourself a lifetime get out of jail card. I imagine some of these scoundrels have the dirt on local authority and know where the bodies are buried, prompting only mild slaps on the wrist and later drinks with the judge and prosecutor. Others, such as a poor kid caught with a joint in his pocket get locked up and the key thrown away.

    It's been going on in these parts for years now, so why change?!

Leave a comment

All comments are initially screened to avoid spam and profanity, and your comment may take some time to appear on the site. The Powell Tribune reserves the right to not publish inappropriate comments.
Fields marked (*) are required.

Subscribe

Get all the latest Powell news by subscribing to the Powell Tribune today!

Click here to find out more!

E-Edition

Our paper can be delivered right to your e-mail inbox with a subscription to the Powell Tribune!

Find out more here!

Stay Connected

Keep up with Powell news by liking us on Facebook or following us on Twitter.

Go to top